Betsy Brown is not the kind of woman who has one-night stands. Then she loses her job. After one too many margaritas, she goes home with a handsome stranger after a farewell party at a local restaurant. Embarrassed and ashamed, she leaves as soon as she comes to her senses and hopes to never see him again. Then she learns that he is the new owner of the company she had worked for. Can she separate herself from that night and her shame when he seems to want to pursue a relationship?
Greg Gunderson is genuinely attracted to Betsy, but when he learns that she is angry at the man who gave her the ax, he doesn't know how to continue. She wants nothing to do with him and he has to make her come around. Then he finds another way to get to know Betsy better. Will it work?
In the meantime, Betsy receives a card from the alumni committee of the American High School for military dependents that she'd attended some twenty years before. She begins an online conversation with her first boyfriend. Now she must decide which one to choose: the man from her past or the one from the present. Which one is right for her future?